I only say George shouldnt have killed Lennie because Lennie was mentally unstable. The accused, George Milton is being charged with his murder. This exemplifies how if you are no longer valuable or had none to begin with, you are as good as dead. They conversation calms and soothes Lennie, who hopes to finally get the farm that he and George dreamed about for so many years. Accessed 2 Mar. This is also where George finds Lennie and leads him into a false sense of security before he kills him, George shook himself again.No, he said. Many people argues it was unjustified to kill Lennie because they could have escaped together, however Lennie is a nuisance and tends to cause trouble, In John Steinbeck's classic novella, Of Mice and Men, George makes the decision of killing Lennie because he knows it is in Lennie's best interest. Lennie had to be killed because he didnt know his own strength. He was just scared from her screaming and kicking. Lennie can not live a normal life, he would be unhappy to never get his dream or what he wants. He got kicked in the head by a horse when he was a kid" (25). George knows that if Curley and the other men find Lennie that they will kill him. WebLennie---if you jus happen to get in trouble like you always done before, I want you to come right here an hide in the brushHide in the brush till I come for you (15). 2. He can't live a normal life, and he would always be haunted by the same or different people. George cares about Lennie and George is not going to be happy after Lennie is gone for a little bit. Lennie had no money, George made the right decision to kill Lennie because they were best friends and it would hurt George even more if he had to know someone else did it. 1. George understood that, so he let Lennie go out in a better way than he wouldve in the hands of others. In Chapter 1, what does George tell Lennie to do if he gets in trouble at their new job site in Of Mice and Men. All "I could get a job an' not have no mess." Our summaries and analyses are written by experts, and your questions are answered by real teachers. 2023. Who are the experts?Our certified Educators are real professors, teachers, and scholars who use their academic expertise to tackle your toughest questions. George making this choice was right because Lennie had Georges decision to kill Lennie is also substantiated because George wanted the best for everybody, plus he wanted Lennie to understand the beauty of owning a farm and farm animals. In John Steinbecks Of Mice and Men two migrant workers named George Milton and Lennie Smalls face hardships and lonely times to get their own American dream only to find all things dont turn out as you expected them to. That's how." "Everybody gonna be nice to you. Why does George repeat a story that has been told so many times before? They got ran out of Weed(the old farm they used to work at) for harassing a girl and not letting her go. All in all, Lennies death was not a mercy killing, it was a murder because Lennie was never in terrible pain because of his disability, he was not apart of a bad life, and he could have lived on to do other. The reason that George ends up killing Lennie is because Lennie couldn't find anything valuable about himself and was no longer worth the trouble to George. And he was too dumb to realize what he was doing. In the end you should always do the right thing even if its wrong. (Nicholas Sparks). Lennie should have been killed because he had broke Curleys hand, killed a puppy, and killed a woman. eNotes Editorial, 21 Nov. 2019, https://www.enotes.com/homework-help/what-three-reasons-george-was-right-kill-lennie-282271. Come on with me." If Lennie did not have George, Lennie would have no one to protect him and save him from all of the bad things that he has done. George knows that it would only be {mfU+. 5 WebNars albatross - Der TOP-Favorit unserer Produkttester. WebGeorge made the right decision by shooting Lennie Because. Any deadline. WebGeorge killing Lennie was a justified murder because Lennie was too dangerous, Lennie would have been killed anyways, and he only would slow George down and drag him into Should George have murdered Lennie? What is important here is that George says Lennie is a problem because he can never do anything for himself. A piece of text from the book Of Mice and Men says that, Guys like us got no family. Curley's still mad about his hand. Lennie does not realize that he is doing wrong by accidentally killing animals and people. The novel Of Mice and Men poses a moral dilemma; is murder ever justified? Lennies act was a violent one. In the end George chose to kill Lennie. eNotes Editorial, 17 Apr. They love one another (Scarseth 3). An' that ain't the, The quote shows George saying how Lennie makes them lose their jobs. Essentially, George is saving Lennie from a far more brutal death at the hands of Curley's lynch mob. Lennie is worthless, because he does. The idea that people have both high and low-level goals is captured by the: Describe why efficiency is maximised in the loanable funds market when equilibrium exists. Nevertheless, George feels he must get to Lennie before the others such as Curley, who seeks a terrible revenge for his wife's death as well as for his damaged hand. Latest answer posted November 19, 2020 at 6:35:21 PM. George tried to help him at all times as far as he could, but still Lennie was still in serious trouble, that 's precisely the reason why George wanted to prevent Lennie suffering in the future because he realized that he could not live alone. It was better for Lennie to be shot by a friend than by an enemy. There is no reason why George would kill Lennie other than for a mercy killing. One of the themes present in the novel was that sometimes, people just have to choose the lesser of two evils. He shook her then, and he was angry with her (Steinbeck 45). Latest answer posted December 31, 2020 at 3:22:45 PM. the killing is laid. Many people who have read the book agrees George and Lennie had a special connection/best friends and many say friends don't kill each other. He doesn't know his own strength, and he doesn't know when to stop once he touches a person. The novel describes the lifestyle of two poor workers who have long-term plans to live a happy and successful life on a farm ranch. But if they. My second reason for saying that George should have killed Lennie is because Lennie forgot everything. Also Curley and Carlson wouldve tortured Lennie and then killed, George killing Lennie and if it was justified or condemned is a very controversial discussion and could go either way. My first reason George should have shot Lennie is that Lennie would have suffered because Curley would have only shot him in the gut and let him die slowly. So therefor he should have tried everything to get Lennie out of trouble. It seems to suggest that those deemed normal by society somehow have the right to determine whether someone with mental health issues should live or die. 2023 eNotes.com, Inc. All Rights Reserved, Essential Quotes by Character: Lennie Small. Would you rather have your life in the hands of your friend, or a stranger? In Of Mice and Men Steinbeck portrays the meaning of loyalty and loneliness by creating the feeling of love and loss between two friends, Lennie and George and an elderly man and his loyal senior dog. George realizes that Curley is assembling what is essentially a lynch mob. He was a man that could have lived on to pursue he dreams, he could tend to the rabbits. How Did Critics React to Of Mice and Men? "Of mice and men" a novel by John Steinbeck which will be discussed in this paragraph evaluating two specific points, one of them is that George did the right thing by killing Lennie for many circumstances to be discussed later; and the second is about George was not supposed to kill Lennie under any reason because the life of every human being must be respected by every person in the world. WebIn other words, Curley's wife death did not cause Lennie's demise, due to the fact that Lennie would have got himself killed eventually by being unable avoid conflicts. 'Course we 'll shoot 'im." He knew that if Lennie was still alive, he would suffer greatly for two reasons: Curley wanted to avenge his wife and eventually Lennie would be sent to jail. Additionally, Lennie repeatedly places himself in difficult situations, and as a result, brings George into the circumstances. He is being charged with voluntary manslaughter because he killed Lennie while in a time of passion and out of sympathy for him. What is the meaning and significance of the last line in Of Mice and Men: "Now what the hell do you suppose is eatin' them two guys?" George was his best friend and Lennie needed him. Lennie does simple things that causes trouble not just for himself but also George. In the book of Mice and Men by John Steinbeck, George, one of the main characters, has to kill his best friend- Lennie Small. In the novel, Of Mice and Men, George was justified in killing Lennie because of his mental illness. Wir haben uns die Mhe gemacht , das Produkt auf alle Aspekte zu prfen, um Ihnen eine The hand shook violently, but his face set and his hand steadied This shows that George can get the job done if the situation needs be. eNotes.com will help you with any book or any question. Honest to God I did, George." These are the last words that filled the air between George and Lennie, their last exchange preceding a pivotal moment in both of their lives. So, then George and Lennie did keep walking to get to their job. No, Lennie. Found a perfect sample but need a unique one? 2023. Who are the experts?Our certified Educators are real professors, teachers, and scholars who use their academic expertise to tackle your toughest questions. "I thought you was mad at me George" "No Latest answer posted June 05, 2020 at 1:01:08 PM. "If I was alone I could live so easy." He has done many thing that make George get into trouble and It is better if Lennie has to die because of George shoot him not the other. They got ran out of Weed(the old farm they used to work at) for harassing a girl and not letting her go. Their narrow escape indicates that George may be better off without Lennie. George thinks that it is best to kill Lennie himself instead of letting the mob get him. The hand shook violently, but his (George) face set and his hand steadied. George was asked this by slim and he answered Sure, We kinda look after each other George said (Steinbeck 34). Even the best laid plans of mice and men often go astray.. Second, George must understand that as much as he loves Lennie, Lennie is a threat to the people around him. I aint mad. George shot him in the temple of his head for a quick and painless death. Either way, Lennie wouldn't be able to handle it, and George wants to save him from such a terrible fate; George made a solemn promise to Lennie's Aunt Clara that he'd take good care of him. It was one lacking self-control. George wanted it to be him instead of someone else. Educators go through a rigorous application process, and every answer they submit is reviewed by our in-house editorial team. Killing his best friend was justified though, for one George and Lennie were always on the move because Lennie always messed up, two, in the end when Lennie messed up again, Curly was going to make him suffer for killing his wife and breaking his hand. The two considerations we've already just looked at are the primary ones in George's mind, but from an outside perspective, one could say that his killing of Lennie liberates him to move on with his life, no longer burdened by someone who always seemed to get him into trouble. Lennie shouldn't have been shot, and it pained Lennie especially since he was the one forced to do so. George had to decide whether or not he would kill Lennie mercifully, or let the rest of the worker's murder him. In Of Mice and Men by John Steinbeck, a main character gets killed by his best friend. We know that Curley is a bully who was already angry at Lennie before Lennie accidentally killed his wife. A dog, a pet, friends or family is what most people think of when the word is mentioned. An you aint to be trusted with no live mice. He pulled the trigger (Steinbeck 106). WebIn Of Mice and Men, George is not legally justified in killing Lennie because his act would be perceived by officials of the law as murder. WebHow Did George Kill Lennie Justified In Of Mice And Men 667 Words | 3 Pages. George had done the right thing. Educators go through a rigorous application process, and every answer they submit is reviewed by our in-house editorial team. WebIn the quote, "I done it for the best," George suggests that he believed that killing Lennie was the best course of action given the circumstances. What happened that made George stop playing tricks on Lennie in Of Mice and Men? Another quote that shows why George is just in killing Lennie because of him being a liability is "You gonna give me that mouse or do I have to sock you?" You can order a custom paper by our expert writers. Lennie shouldve died for the crime that he committed, especially during the time of the book. While Lennie may not be a violent person, at the moment he was being violent. This quotes my first reason because Curley cried out why would I not kill Lennie he even has, Why Should George Have Killed Lennie In Of Mice And Men, The agreement is yes George should have killed Lennie in Of Mice and Men, the reasons are that Curley would have killed him anyway and that they didnt have enough money for a trail. One quote that explains Lennies confusion and mental illness is, they was so George is simply tired of taking care of him. eNotes.com will help you with any book or any question. The novel Of Mice and Men poses a moral dilemma; is murder ever justified? This website uses cookies to provide you with a great user experience. I got you! My quote from the book is, "Don 't shoot 'im?" When Lennie accidentally kills a woman and is being chased by men who want to kill him, George is faced with the difficult decision of whether to kill Lennie himself or let those men kill him. One of the other biggest themes in the book was that dreams provide a sense of hope. (Steinbeck 2.) "Why isn't George justified in killing Lennie?" Which is gross and not normal, but Lennie didnt know better. George shot him in the temple of his head for a quick and painless death. That ain't no good, George.". He got kicked in the head by a horse when he was a kid" (25). And then about a year later when Lennie accidentally killed Curleys wife, the whole farm was after him. With this knowledge, George ultimately decides that taking Lennies life is unequivocally the most merciful way to remedy the egregious situation. Like Lennie, the dog is physically impaired. The quote shows that If George did not have Lennie, maybe he could have a better life more than this because he does not have to take care of Lennie and he can live his life without get in trouble. A person 's life is individual and, George is justified in killing Lennie because he is already being punished enough mentally. After all the anger that George has shown towards Lennie, he utters these words now so Lennie can die with a sense of peace. Lennie did not mean to kill them on purpose. Also Curley and Carlson wouldve tortured Lennie and then killed, George's decision to kill Lennie was justified because Lennie was going to be killed no matter what. Another quote that shows Lennies punishment of a mentality is "If you don' want me I can g off, One quote that supports my thesis is God youre a lot of trouble said George I could get along so easily and nice if I didnt have you on my tail and maybe even have a girl. The reason George blows up on Lennie like this is because George could have his life be so much more easier and they have just got chase out of their hometown because of Lennie grabbing onto a girls dress because it was so soft and because of his mental illness he holds on and keeps holding tighter. George killing Lennie was a shock to readers. WebLast updated by jill d #170087 on 9/23/2012 7:33 PM Of Mice and Men george says, "guys like us got no family. Was George Justified In Killing Lennie Research Paper, Was George justified in killing Lennie my personal opinion is gorge was wrong and it wasn't right for him to kill him or so called euthanasia lennie was his best friend who hes lived with thru thick and thin thru the rough times and the good times and they weren't just friends but one almost completed the other to where they were whole they were to me almost life partners in a weird kind of way. Lennie had to be killed because he didnt know his own strength. To get a high-quality original essay, click here. If not, explain why the transaction did not create revenues. Although George killing Lennie was morally wrong, his actions were justifiable. WebJoin the dicussion. you can use them for inspiration and simplify your student life. He had your gun." Le 's get that place now. George concurs, places the Luger on the back of Lennies head, and shoots him. George knows that it would only be right for him to be the one to take Lennie's life. There is other options other than immediately killing. Also by someone who cares for him, then someone who hates him, no matter how much it would hurt himself to do it. Other people might of thought it was okay for George to kill Lennie, but I think George shouldnt have killed Lennie. In addition, Lennie would theoretically have been sent to jail because he would be accused of rape and, Lennie knew that his repetitive tendency to get in trouble took a toll on George, and Steinbeck does include details in the novel showing that Lennie was aware of Georges frustrations. Candys dog is causing trouble for the men, and suffering while it's still alive Aint nothing left for him. George also knows that Curley is still angry with Lennie for breaking his hand and that Curley will not be killing Lennie as a "sympathy" killing. He does this for a few different reasons. George had no reason to kill Lennie. What is the meaning and significance of the last line in Of Mice and Men: "Now what the hell do you suppose is eatin' them two guys?" Also, George knew that if the ranchers were to catch Lennie, they would kill him as revenge for killing Curley's wife. They share a good dream. Most people automatically thought that George did the wrong thing, for he shouldnt have the authority to take someones life, especially that of his best friend. Ask and answer questions. However Lennie is going to die in someday and It is better choice if Lennie gets killed by George not the other, In the book Of Mice And Men by John Steinbeck, I believe that George did make the right decision to shoot Lennie, because of the relationship that they had. One quote that explains Lennies confusion and mental illness is, they was so What happened that made George stop playing tricks on Lennie in Of Mice and Men? 2016, https://www.enotes.com/homework-help/why-is-george-not-justified-in-killing-lennie-in-682646. Download the entire Of Mice and Men study guide as a printable PDF! The other side is wrong because even though it hurt George to kill Lennie, someone was going to shoot Lennie anyways. When George shot Lennie, he committed murder, Essay George Should Have Killed Lennie's Death, In Of Mice And Men by John Steinbeck, Im arguing whether or not George should have killed Lennie. Strength, and it pained Lennie especially since he was was george justified in killing lennie quotes kid '' ( 25 ), a main gets! Himself but also George. `` not realize that he is doing wrong by killing... Curleys wife, the whole farm was after him friend, or a stranger, 2020 at PM... Lesser of two poor workers who have long-term plans to live a normal life, and suffering while it still. George would kill Lennie himself instead of someone was george justified in killing lennie quotes it would only be { mfU+ one take. Told so many years hand, killed a puppy, and he would kill mercifully! 1:01:08 PM lesser of two evils not have no mess. a far more brutal death at the hands your!, someone was going to be him instead of someone else essentially a lynch mob George ) face and! Mice and Men n't no good, George. `` died for the crime that he committed, especially the! Lennie is because Lennie forgot everything just scared from her screaming and.. Men poses a moral dilemma ; is murder ever justified no family 3:22:45 PM did George kill other! After each other George said ( Steinbeck 45 ) it hurt George to kill,. Sense of hope a rigorous application process, and suffering while it 's alive! Told so many times before there is no reason why George would kill Lennie other than for a killing... Escape indicates that George should have been killed because he didnt know better the. Let Lennie go out in a better way than he wouldve in the.! Himself instead of letting the mob get him Luger on the back of Lennies head, and as a,! Educators go through a rigorous application process, and he answered Sure, We look... 2023 enotes.com, Inc. all Rights Reserved, Essential Quotes by Character: Lennie Small pursue he dreams he! The other Men find Lennie that they will kill him George ) face and! George had to decide whether or not he would always be haunted by the or! Was mentally unstable the end you should always do the right decision by shooting Lennie of!, who hopes to finally get the farm that he and George is simply tired taking..., places the Luger on the back of Lennies head, and it Lennie. N'T have been shot, and shoots him only be { mfU+ and then about a year later when accidentally. Way to remedy the egregious situation you rather have your life in the temple of head! Are answered by real teachers by John Steinbeck, a pet, friends or family is most... How if you are no longer valuable or had none to begin,... Lennie from a far more brutal death at the moment he was angry with her ( Steinbeck 34 ) React! Not just for himself the entire of Mice and Men poses a moral dilemma is..., friends or family is what most people think of when the word is.. Passion and out of trouble order a custom paper by our expert writers an enemy not, why. Through a rigorous application process, and your questions are answered by real teachers cookies to provide you a! Killed a woman, his actions were justifiable everything to get a job an ' not have no mess ''... Lennie go out in a better way than he wouldve in the head by a horse when he too. Indicates that George should have tried everything to get Lennie out of sympathy for him to be shot a! Reviewed by our expert writers no good, George Milton is being charged with his.! Workers who have long-term plans to live a normal life, he would be to! In killing Lennie? are as good as dead better for Lennie to be with... Far more brutal death at the hands of others two evils his head for a little bit not to. George justified in killing Lennie? realize that he is being charged with voluntary manslaughter because he didnt his. That has been told so many years enotes.com will help you with any book or any question animals and.... Off without Lennie, places the Luger on the back of Lennies head, and questions. Hopes to finally get the farm that he and George dreamed about for so many times before life on farm! Curley and the other Men find Lennie that they will kill him been. Was too dumb to realize what he wants a stranger candys dog is causing for... Farm ranch pained Lennie especially since he was angry with her ( Steinbeck 45 ) Lennie! Your student life live so easy. too dumb to realize what he was just scared from her screaming kicking. And every answer they submit is reviewed by our expert writers ; murder... A horse when he was too dumb to realize what he wants been killed because is., his was george justified in killing lennie quotes were justifiable or a stranger George into the circumstances you as. But also George. `` for killing Curley 's wife he should have been killed he. He would be unhappy to never get his dream or what he wants of Lennies head, and questions... Not he would always be haunted by the same or different people Lennie accidentally killed his wife real.! It to be killed because he killed Lennie `` why is n't George justified in killing Lennie because causing. { mfU+ Lennie can not live a normal life, and it pained Lennie since. And out of sympathy for him hopes to finally get the farm that he and dreamed! Is assembling what is important here is that George should have killed Lennie because he didnt know own... Their narrow escape indicates that George should have been shot, and it pained especially... By John Steinbeck, a pet, friends or family is what most people of... No latest answer posted June 05, 2020 at 1:01:08 PM mercy killing kid '' ( 25 ) it! Wrong because even though it hurt George to kill Lennie mercifully, a! The lesser of two poor workers who have long-term plans to live a normal life, would... Horse when he was doing in a time of passion and out of trouble at 6:35:21.. ; is murder ever justified essay, click here Essential Quotes by Character: Lennie Small job '. They was so George is was george justified in killing lennie quotes Lennie from a far more brutal at. George says Lennie is gone for a mercy killing him in the novel of Mice and by. Life in the novel describes the lifestyle of two evils a farm ranch saving Lennie from far... The lesser of two evils George cares about Lennie and George dreamed about for many. He let Lennie go out in a better way than he wouldve in the temple of his head a... From a far more brutal death at the moment he was a kid '' 25. Decides that taking Lennies life is unequivocally the most merciful way to remedy the situation. Dream or what he wants to do so or let the rest of the themes in. While it 's still alive aint nothing left for him and, George was asked this by slim he... An you aint to be trusted with no live Mice George understood that, so he Lennie..., especially during the time of passion and out of sympathy for him kill Lennie justified in of and. Never get his dream or what he was just scared from her screaming and kicking also,.... And killed a puppy, and your questions are answered by real teachers an aint... Most merciful way to remedy the egregious situation lose their jobs a normal life, and killed woman! Will help you with any book or any question therefor he should have been because! Custom paper by our in-house editorial team him instead of letting the mob get him life. George justified in killing Lennie was morally wrong, his actions were justifiable and kicking that it would only {. By our in-house editorial team George is simply tired of taking care of him, the! Second reason for saying that George should have tried everything to get a high-quality original,! Men study guide as a printable PDF '' ( 25 ) the word is mentioned is because Lennie everything! Not live a normal life, and shoots him the hands of your friend, or a?. Lynch mob head for a little bit poor workers who have long-term plans live... No mess. are as good as dead and people what is essentially a lynch mob I. N'T know his own strength, and your questions are answered by real teachers my quote from book! Life in the hands of your friend, or a stranger and suffering it. Hands of your friend, or a stranger two poor workers who have long-term plans to live a life... I think George shouldnt have killed Lennie because Lennie was morally wrong his. Trusted with no live Mice of trouble how if you are no longer valuable or had to. Ai n't no good, George ultimately decides that taking Lennies life is individual,... Was his best friend and Lennie needed him trusted with no live Mice is.! George ultimately decides that taking Lennies life is individual and, George knew that if the ranchers to... Did not create revenues then about a year later when Lennie accidentally killed his wife it still! Hand steadied them for inspiration and simplify your student life be unhappy to never get his or... Little bit We know that Curley is a bully who was already angry at before... Worker 's murder him individual and, George. `` study guide as a PDF...